news

Milburn report urges gradual cut to under-25 National Insurance

News

· news, politics, business

Young apprentice hairdresser working in a UK salon beside an older stylist
Photo by Suzy Hazelwood / Pexels · source

A government-commissioned review by former Labour health secretary Alan Milburn will recommend gradually lowering employer National Insurance contributions for workers aged 21 to 24 over five years, starting in the retail and hospitality sectors, according to the BBC. The independent report, a year in the making, is due to be published Tuesday and will also set out ways to cut the UK's benefits bill for young people.

The recommendation lands against a backdrop that the government itself created: under Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer, ministers raised employer National Insurance, a move business groups blamed for slowing hiring. Milburn's report, the BBC reports, will say that rise is not what started the rise in so-called Neets — young people not in employment, education or training.

What exactly does the Milburn report propose?

The core recommendation is a phased reduction in employer NI costs for 21- to 24-year-olds, beginning in retail and hospitality before widening to other sectors, the BBC reports. Milburn will also recommend doubling the threshold at which businesses start paying NI for that age group, from £5,000 to £10,000, but only "when fiscal conditions allow," according to the broadcaster's account of the report.

Beyond tax, Milburn wants a legal guarantee of a job, training place, or employment support for young people — paired with a condition that those who turn down the help could lose benefits. He is also expected to argue that skills programs are of limited use if there are no jobs for young people to move into once trained, the BBC reports.

How many young people are affected, and what would it cost?

By the numbers, per BBC reporting:

  • Nearly 1 million people aged 16 to 24 in the UK are classified as Neets, according to Office for National Statistics data cited in the report.
  • The government spends roughly £22 billion a year supporting young people who are economically inactive, Milburn has said.
  • Immediately scrapping employer NI for 21- to 24-year-olds across the board would cost £5.1 billion, according to research by the Resolution Foundation, a left-leaning think tank, cited by the BBC.
  • The NI-free earnings threshold for that age group would rise from £5,000 to £10,000 under the proposal, though only once fiscal conditions permit it.

Milburn is expected to argue that, given the UK's fiscal position, an immediate across-the-board NI cut is not the best use of several billion pounds in public money — hence the phased, sector-first approach, according to the BBC's reporting.

What else does the report say about benefits?

Milburn will recommend that under-25s no longer be able to claim the health element of Universal Credit or Personal Independence Payment, the UK-wide disability benefit, the BBC reports. The proposal pairs that restriction with the job-or-training guarantee, framing conditionality and opportunity as two sides of the same policy rather than a straightforward benefit cut.

What are employers saying about it?

Collette Osborne, who owns three hairdressing salons in Nottingham, told the BBC she feels "suffocated by employment costs," including NI and the minimum wage. She said she once employed eight apprentices a year but can no longer afford to take on any, and her workforce has more than halved to 21 staff. Training an apprentice to the point of working on customers costs roughly £60,000, she said, adding that she is "inundated" with job applications from young people she cannot hire. "I feel like the government's foot is firmly on my neck," Osborne told the BBC. "They promise breathing space. I feel suffocated."

What is the political response?

Shadow Work and Pensions Secretary Helen Whately said the government should "just stop doing the taxing," according to the BBC — a direct jab at the earlier NI increase rather than an endorsement of Milburn's phased fix. The report's framing — that the NI rise did not cause the Neet problem — puts Milburn, a Labour figure, at odds with critics who see the tax itself as the obstacle employers describe.

Timeline: what happens next

  • This week: Milburn's report is published, with recommendations on NI and benefits for under-25s.
  • Over five years: Proposed phased reduction in employer NI for 21- to 24-year-olds, sector by sector, starting with retail and hospitality.
  • Threshold change: Doubling the NI-free earnings threshold to £10,000 is contingent on fiscal conditions, with no fixed date specified in the report as described by the BBC.

What to watch

  • Whether the Treasury adopts the phased NI cut in a future Budget, given the Resolution Foundation's £5.1 billion cost estimate for an immediate version.
  • How ministers respond to the Universal Credit and Pip restrictions for under-25s, which are likely to draw scrutiny from disability and welfare advocates.
  • Whether retail and hospitality employers, like Osborne's salons, see any near-term relief given the report's five-year phase-in.

Milburn's full report and its complete set of recommendations are expected Tuesday, per the BBC's advance reporting.

Disclosure. Legal entity: Pinewood Creations LLC. Smorgi Apps appears only as an affiliate partner in house slots — not as publisher or owner. See our affiliate disclosure.

Questions

What does the Milburn report recommend on National Insurance?

It recommends gradually lowering employer National Insurance contributions for workers aged 21 to 24 over five years, starting in retail and hospitality, and doubling the NI-free earnings threshold from £5,000 to £10,000 when fiscal conditions allow, according to the BBC.

How much would cutting National Insurance for under-25s cost?

The Resolution Foundation estimates an immediate, across-the-board scrapping of employer NI for 21- to 24-year-olds would cost £5.1 billion, as reported by the BBC.

Would the report change benefits for young people?

Yes. Milburn will recommend that under-25s lose access to the health element of Universal Credit and Personal Independence Payment, paired with a guaranteed offer of a job, training, or employment support, per the BBC.

Sources

More from HTT News

Briefing

Top stories from the HTT News network by email. Free. No noise.