Sacramento, Calif. — Newsom's Death Row Plan Sparks DA Revolt

California district attorneys are pushing back against Gov. Gavin Newsom's plan to commute the death sentences of all 548 people on the state's death row, arguing the move overrides jury verdicts and ignores victims' families, according to Fox News.

By the Numbers

• 548 — death row inmates in California covered by Newsom's commutation plan, per Fox News.
• 2026 — the year prosecutors went public with their opposition, according to the Fox News report.

What Is Newsom Proposing to Change?

The plan, as described by Fox News, would commute the death sentences of every inmate currently on California's death row — all 548 of them. A commutation does not mean release; it changes a sentence, typically from death to life in prison, but it removes the possibility of execution. Prosecutors say the scope of the plan — covering the entire death row population rather than individual cases — is what has triggered the backlash.

Why Are Prosecutors Calling It 'Politics Over People'?

California district attorneys accuse Newsom of putting "politics over people," according to Fox News, arguing the governor is substituting his own judgment for verdicts reached by juries in individual criminal trials. The prosecutors also say the plan sidelines the families of murder victims, who in many of these cases sat through trials and sentencing hearings that resulted in death verdicts, Fox News reported.

What Legal Fight Are Prosecutors Warning About?

Fox News reports that prosecutors are warning of a legal fight over the commutations, though the report does not detail which specific legal mechanisms — a court challenge, a ballot measure, or another avenue — district attorneys intend to pursue. The dispute centers on whether a governor's commutation power can be used to clear an entire death row population at once, rather than case by case.

Who Is Affected by the Plan?

The commutations would touch the 548 people currently sentenced to death in California, according to Fox News. District attorneys across the state, who prosecuted these cases and secured the original death verdicts, say they were not meaningfully consulted. Families of victims in those cases are also affected, since a commutation changes the outcome of sentencing proceedings many of them attended.

What Happens Next in California?

The fight over the commutations is continuing, with prosecutors signaling they are prepared to contest the move in court, per Fox News. The report does not specify a timeline for when commutations would take effect or when any legal challenge would be filed. HTT News will update this story as California officials release further details on the plan and on any court filings tied to it.

No Time to Speed — Maps San Francisco automated speed cameras and warns before you cross the ticket threshold.

For a Bay Area-baked gift, Stirred, Not Shaken ships in the U.S.