BBC Podcast Raises New Doubts in Colin Norris Insulin Murder Case

A new BBC podcast has reexamined the medical evidence behind the 2008 murder convictions of nurse Colin Norris and found grounds to question whether the killings happened at all, according to BBC News. The series, Disclosure Investigates: Killer on the Ward, reviewed medical records, police interviews and newer scientific findings tied to the case.

Who did Colin Norris kill, according to the conviction?

Norris, a staff nurse originally from Glasgow, was convicted in 2008 of murdering four elderly patients and attempting to murder a fifth at a Leeds hospital, the BBC reports. The lead victim, 86-year-old Ethel Hall, was recovering from a broken hip when she was found in a hypoglycemic coma in 2002; blood tests showed what prosecutors called a massive amount of insulin in her system, and she died 21 days later. Police then retrospectively reviewed other deaths on Norris's wards and identified three more unexplained severe hypoglycemic deaths and one non-fatal case, according to the outlet.

What evidence convicted him at trial?

No blood samples were taken from the three other deceased patients at the time, the BBC notes, so prosecution experts relied on medical charts showing persistent, severe low blood sugar. They argued in court that such readings were so rare in non-diabetic patients that murder was the only explanation. Defence experts countered that four of the five patients had died of natural causes. After a five-month trial and a deadlocked jury, Norris was convicted by an 11-1 majority and told he would not be eligible for parole for 30 years, per the BBC's account.

What new doubts has the podcast surfaced?

The BBC reports that its review of records, interviews and new scientific findings "reveals a scenario in which the murders may never have taken place at all." Ethel Hall's daughter-in-law, Helen Hall, told the podcast: "The evidence, it's just not sitting right to me." Her comments follow the Court of Appeal's rejection last year of Norris's latest challenge to his convictions, the outlet says.

Has Norris's appeal already failed?

Yes. According to the BBC, the Court of Appeal rejected Norris's challenge to his convictions last year, even as the new podcast was compiling material that some of Ethel Hall's relatives now say has shaken their confidence in the case. Norris, who the BBC notes now goes by the name Colin Campbell, has spent 18 years in prison.

How does this compare with the Lucy Letby case?

The BBC's report notes the podcast arrives a week after a public inquiry reported on former neonatal nurse Lucy Letby, convicted of murdering seven babies and attempting to murder seven others at a Chester hospital roughly a decade ago. The circumstances differ substantially, the outlet stresses, but supporters of both Norris and Letby argue their cases turn on disputed interpretations of medical evidence rather than direct proof of harm.

At the time of Norris's 2007 verdict, Ethel Hall's son Stuart Hall said of the nurse: "I don't think he should come out again. He's got the knowledge to commit murder but do it discreetly," according to the BBC.

No Time to Speed — Maps San Francisco automated speed cameras and warns before you cross the ticket threshold.

For a Bay Area-baked gift, Stirred, Not Shaken ships in the U.S.